With over three decades of history, Magic: The Gathering is an ever-evolving card game where a card's value is rarely set in stone. While power creep today often makes cards look like staples as soon as they're released, there are many times when what defines a staple is simply time: a new interaction, an unexpected combo, or a shift in a particular format's meta—all these factors can skyrocket a piece of bulk into staple status.There are many recent and iconic examples: Dust to Dust in Pauper, for instance, only became what it is today when Affinity became the best deck in the format. Other cases, however, are emblematic stories in the game's history—and that's what we'll focus on today.In this article, we present the history of ten cards that went from "draft chaff" or "bulk rare" to fundamental pieces that shaped (and sometimes broke) the game as we know it.NecropotenceLet's start with the classic.Necropotence is still considered one of the most powerful card advantage engines in Magic: The Gathering and taught the valuable lesson that life is a resource: paying one life to draw a card is much better than preserving that life because your draws expand other resources and provide more threats and answers—but that's not how players and experts saw the enchantment when it was released in Ice Age.The magazine InQuest, responsible for reviews at the time, considered Necropotence one of the worst cards in Ice Age. The cost of skipping your draw step and having to pay life to draw cards was a notoriously bad effect, while, curiously, the same magazine pointed to Jester's Cap as the best rare in the set.But any illusion that it was bad quickly faded: Necropotence proved so powerful it defined the Standard of its era during the infamous "Black Summer," culminating in leaving such a mark that it led to its banning in Extended and Legacy and restriction in Vintage—a fate also shared by Yawgmoth's Bargain, the "fixed" version of the enchantment.Decades later, Necropotence is legal in the Timeless format on Magic Arena, where it headlines a dominant archetype that took five of the eight Top 8 slots in the last 2025 Arena Championship.TarmogoyfTarmogoyf followed a similar trajectory to Necropotence, except there were no experts saying the card was bad: the player base itself decided that when the creature was revealed in Future Sight, being the first preview of the Planeswalker type in Magic's history.Many players looked at the green creature whose body depended on card types in graveyards and asked, "So what?" The answer came quickly in the first weeks after Future Sight's release: tournament after tournament, more decks started using Tarmogoyf because its rate for the cost was too efficient: even if it started as a 2/3 for , it would eventually grow to larger proportions if your list allowed it.You didn't even need to dedicate a list to growing its body because it would do that naturally: discards, removal, and creatures in the graveyard would already turn Goyf into a respectable threat and redefine what "efficient mana threat" meant for competitive Magic—every creature would now be compared to Tarmogoyf, and for years, they didn't even come close to being as good.Eternal formats went even further: the interaction between Tarmogoyf, Fetch Lands, and cheap spells served as a driver for various distinct versions of Tempo and Midrange archetypes, and Goyf's staple status was solidified for over a decade, including being one of the most expensive cards in Modern for years and the main reason for reprint sets like Modern Masters to exist.Death’s ShadowReleased in Worldwake, Death's Shadow was initially met with disdain. At the time, Mark Rosewater was already doing his famous previews of what to expect from the next set, and his comment on the card was of a "13/13 creature for one mana"—a clear reference to Phyrexian Dreadnought, a Legacy staple alongside Stifle.When revealed, little importance was given to Shadow, and the card only showed early signs of potential interactions when Varolz, the Scar-Striped was released in Dragon's Maze, where, in theory, Death's Shadow would be used as fuel to put 13 +1/+1 counters on a creature.Its status as a staple, unlike other cards, was gradual. Death's Shadow appeared in pseudo-combo lists with Phyrexian Unlife from time to time in Modern, and the Tarkir block gave rise to Shadow Zoo, which aimed to maximize the use of Fetch Lands and Shock Lands to feed the graveyard and use the Become Immense and Temur Battle Rage combo more consistently, but it was still stuck in the Tier D of the format.Its redemption and eventual success came from a shift in mindset on how to approach Midrange in Modern: in a format full of Fetch Lands and Shock Lands, it was already evident that the mana base did enough to control life total and ensure Death's Shadow grew, it just needed the rest to work, and Josh Utter-Leyton was the first player to post a significant result with Jund Shadow, a Jund variant that gave up incremental card advantage for a more explosive clock and mana efficiency—out went Dark Confidant, Kalitas Traitor of Ghet and Huntmaster of the Fells, and in came Street Wraith, Mishra's Bauble and Traverse the Ulvenwald.The shift towards a more aggressive Jund proposal was due to the meta of the time, where traditional Jund was very unfavored against the rise of Big Mana and Combo archetypes like Scapeshift and Tron—two matchups where Death's Shadow's more aggressive clock shined—and soon the new version became the best deck in the format, culminating in players looking for answers within Shadow itself in a new variant, where Tarmogoyf and the entire green base were cut, and blue was added with Snapcaster Mage, cheap cantrips, plus Gurmag Angler and Stubborn Denial.Thus Grixis Shadow was born, which dominated the Modern meta throughout 2017 and forced the format to adapt against a strategy that was always available but always under the radar, complete with a video from Luis-Scott Vargas calling for a Death's Shadow ban when the card Claim // Fame was revealed.Mishra’s BaubleMishra's Bauble was ignored for over a decade, and its rise was initially tied to the card's popularization with Jund Shadow: suddenly, the "Artifact" type became relevant for feeding Tarmogoyf and the Delirium of Traverse the Ulvenwald while providing a free cantrip that allowed reducing the number of lands in the list while manipulating your topdeck with Fetch Lands or the opponent's topdeck for more information after a Thoughtseize.Over time, Lantern Control also started using the artifact as part of its plan to manipulate the opponent's deck top to control their draws, and as years passed, Bauble became more important: the Companion mechanic turned it into a recurring source of card advantage with Lurrus of the Dream-Den, and suddenly every archetype that could run Lurrus in Modern wanted to use Baubles to generate value every turn, culminating in one of the reasons for Lurrus's ban.Modern Horizons 2 brought Dragon's Rage Channeler and Unholy Heat, two cards with Delirium mechanics that became the core of Izzet Murktide, the dominant strategy in the format that used four copies of this artifact to feed the graveyard, both to increase DRC's power and to speed up casting Murktide Regent.Today, Mishra's Bauble remains an important staple in Modern—whether alongside Emry, Lurker of the Loch, Cori-Steel Cutter, or the combination of Mox Opal, Pinnacle Emissary, and Kappa Cannoneer in Affinity, making it one of the most iconic cards in the format today.Lion’s Eye DiamondThe story of Lion's Eye Diamond is perhaps the most iconic on this list. In Mirage, it was seen as a bad joke: a Black Lotus that required you to discard your hand and could only be activated when you could cast an instant made many players consider it one of the worst cards in history.The turnaround came from a combination of rule adjustments and the release of Infernal Tutor. Players realized that by casting a spell and holding priority, they could activate Lion's Eye Diamond, discard their hand, and then resolve the original spell while gaining three mana in the process, turning LED into a combo engine for Storm in Legacy and Vintage, where, combined with the ability to search for any card from the deck with Infernal Tutor or from the sideboard with Burning Wish, it allowed for more explosive plays that eventually culminated in its price exceeding $500.This line of play, added to the then-combination of "Bomberman" (using Auriok Salvagers to generate infinite mana with LED) also led to the restriction of Lion's Eye Diamond in Vintage, alongside the Black Lotus that players once treated with disdain because of the original card.FlashFlash is responsible for one of the most controversial and confusing rule change stories in Magic. Originally released in Mirage, the card received an errata in 1999 due to an interaction with Academy Rector, and the change was made so the "combo" between these two cards would no longer work.However, in 2007, Magic underwent another official rule change and clarification for various cards in its official database, and in it, Flash received a new errata, reverting the card to its original text, almost a year after the Dissension expansion brought the card Protean Hulk, whose ability to search for creatures with total mana value six or less at the moment it died interacted a little too well with the sacrifice trigger of the blue spell—thus Flash Hulk was born, considered to this day one of the most broken decks in Legacy history.The archetype could win on the first or second turn with absurd consistency and dominated Legacy so thoroughly that it was common to find lists whose main strategy was to combat Flash Hulk. As pointed out by Christopher Coppola in an article for StarCityGames at the time, you could run into an Affinity list using a full set of Pithing Needle and Tormod's Crypt just to deal with the combo.A few months later, the 2007 Grand Prix Columbus—the largest Legacy tournament that year with 887 players—was dominated by Flash Hulk, leading to the card being banned in June, leaving its mark on competitive Magic history. The card was later also banned in Commander in 2020.Bazaar of BaghdadReleased in 1994, Bazaar of Baghdad has many stories and a mechanic that turns Magic into an entirely different game behind its success. Drawing two cards and discarding three was notoriously bad in terms of card advantage and seemed to go in the opposite direction of Library of Alexandria, named by many as the "Power 10" alongside the famous Power 9 list.The years were generous to the land: before Legacy as we know it existed, there was the Type 1.5 format, an unofficial format born in 2004, created by players aiming to ban restricted cards from Type 1 (current Vintage). In it, there was an archetype called "Dragon.dec" using Bazaar of Baghdad with Reanimate to win the game (while the exact list is not available, it is presumed the archetype was the Worldgorger Dragon and Animate Dead combo), which may have contributed to, when Legacy was officially announced in 2006, the card entering the first Banned list of the format.Its true revolution, however, came with the Dredge mechanic in Ravnica. Suddenly, discarding cards to draw more cards was the central goal of a strategy that could even use Magic's mana system and Magic cards but seemed to play an entirely different kind of game than a normal Magic deck.Bazaar became the perfect engine for the archetype: it drew cards to find or recover a Dredge card and discarded three, filling the graveyard with payoffs and elevating the archetype to a level of consistency that makes it a recognized force in the format to this day and ensures Bazaar of Baghdad can never leave the Legacy banlist.Dark DepthsDark Depths was the impossible dream, and there was genuine frustration that the Coldsnap promo was the land's token: a total of 30 mana to remove all ice counters was too slow and a high investment, especially on a card that didn't produce mana and "ate" your land drop, putting you behind in the game.Combos did exist when the card was released: Aether Snap removed its counters instantly for five mana and ensured the 20/20 Marit Lage token entered the battlefield, but it required too much effort and at least six turns to work.Its status as a staple arises from a card that wasn't originally designed with Dark Depths in mind: Vampire Hexmage had a line of text that made it the first creature with an ability that allowed destroying Planeswalkers, but players soon realized they could sacrifice it to remove all counters from Dark Depths and get a Marit Lage token on turn two.Suddenly, HexDepths was the best deck in Extended, and it merged with the Thopter Foundry and Sword of the Meek combo to create a deck consistent in executing two distinct combos that could operate very well in a Control shell: Depths attacked the early game and never lost utility, while Thopter Sword provided inevitability in the late game if the player searched for a Time Sieve and had six mana available to take infinite turns.Years later, Thespian's Stage universalized Dark Depths for other colors, and although the card was preemptively banned in Modern, it remains a Legacy staple in various two-color variants and even in an explosive Mono Black version.Hypergenesis / Living EndTime Spiral brought a cycle of cards with Suspend that had no mana cost, and the only way to play them was by casting them at the start of the game and hoping the match lasted enough turns for them to resolve. Some staples, like Lotus Bloom, found homes even in the Standard of that time in Dragonstorm lists, and Ancestral Vision was present in various blue decks for years due to the long-term card advantage it offered to archetypes like Faeries, but other cards weren't as lucky.Other pieces like Hypergenesis did have potential and saw some play, but required too much setup and their plays were too telegraphed to the point where the opponent could easily prepare a Counterspell or any other spell to solve the problem when the three turns ended, making it just a fun combo, but Alara Reborn changed the perception of mana costs with the Cascade mechanic.Cards like Violent Outburst and Ardent Plea allowed "ignoring" the Suspend cost because they only saw the card's mana value and not its cost, and for practical purposes, every spell with no mana cost had a value of zero—all it took was to build a list around this interaction, and suddenly Hypergenesis had become an Extended staple and one of the format's fastest decks, culminating in its preemptive ban in Modern in 2011.But the Cascade mechanic remained a strong representative in the format: Living End leveraged the Cycling mechanic years later to create an archetype that could consistently present twenty or more power on the board as early as turn three, and it evolved year after year until it reached the point where it remains one of the most important decks in Modern today, with a base entirely restructured compared to its original list.Cascade, in fact, became one of the most controversial and broken mechanics in Magic over the years. Cards like Beck // Call and Valki, God of Lies tested the limits of archetypes based on circumventing these mandatory alternative costs to the point where Wizards of the Coast issued an errata, making Cascade see, in double-faced or modal cards, the combined mana value of both parts.Rhystic StudyRhystic Study was part of a mechanic that, while seeming like an interesting way to tax the opponent's mana, was easy to play around or ignore because it was an inconsistent source of card advantage, and so it remains in the 1v1 environment to this day.What saved it and turned it into one of the most coveted cards by Magic players today was the popularization of Commander and the format's transformation into the "main way to play Magic" for most of the audience: at a multiplayer table, it is logistically impossible for all three opponents to pay one extra mana for every spell they cast.As a result, Rhystic Study transformed into a guaranteed card-drawing machine almost every turn cycle, generating a massive and inevitable advantage that made the phrase "will you pay the one?" one of the most hated in the community, earning it a spot as one of the format's main Game Changers today.Wrapping UpThat's all for today!If you have any questions, feel free to leave a comment!Thanks for reading!
Sign in and join the conversation
— Comments 0
, Reactions 1
Be the first to comment