Top 5 Worst green cards in Magic: The Gathering

Magic: the Gathering

Opinion

Top 5 Worst green cards in Magic: The Gathering

03/29/22 Comment regular icon0 comments

Green is one of the strongest colors in Magic. But back then, it wasn't that great, and today I bring some of the worst green cards ever printed in Magic!

Writer image

translated by Romeu

Writer image

revised by Tabata Marques

Edit Article
In Magic, we can build decks with a vast collection of thousands of cards, ensuring there is a place for each of these strategies. In recent years, the color green has been on an obvious rise, evident by cards like Oko, Thief of Crowns and Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath, as well as Esika's Chariot. Green has never been as good as it is in the game today, but in the past, the color suffered a lot. Its cards were often considered some of the weakest of their cycles, such as Bounty of the Hunt, which could be considered a decent combat trick, putting counters on creatures until the end of the turn, except that this card is part of the same cycle as Force of Will, putting the green spell to shame.

Ad

To prove that Green wasn't always the pinnacle of strength in Magic, we're going to talk about the worst green cards of all time.

Worst Green Cards in Magic

Shelkin Brownie -No Crowds!

Loading icon
Owner of an ability that would be very well seen at the height of the pandemic, Shelkin Brownie can disable the effect of cards with "banding", making the combat fairer for mere mortals like us, who have no idea on how it works. It is a powerful silver bullet against the thirty or so creatures possessing the ability. Realistically, the pixie has the power to disable an ability notoriously known for having rules that are too complicated for how ineffective they are. Made to be a protection against an ability that never actually saw play, Shelkin Brownie becomes a joke for the fact that its effect could have been anything, but it became a measure to protect against a keyword that no one needed to protect themselves from.

Camouflage - Hiding your chances of victory

Loading icon
Camouflage does have a utility, that of trying to create illegal blocks, and that will be negated, causing your creatures to pass straight through to deal combat damage. But counting on that is the same as counting on a good episode of The Simpsons in the new seasons. It may happen, but your expectation will also be your suffering. The card's real use is to prevent your opponent from cheating against you. If you are suspicious of some suspicious activity, a possible theft on your opponent's part, but you prefer not to get their attention by calling the judge out loud, just cast Camouflage, and the whole judge team will come to your table gladly. The card rules in their revised version, available in Gatherer, are a bit complicated when first read. Describing piles of creatures, which may or may not be empty, additional piles with more than one creature, and even the idea that creatures that can block more than one creature occupy multiple piles at the same time, makes this card have a certain effort to explain. To make matters worse, this card was only printed in its version for old rules, which dates back to the creation of the Morph mechanic. Not only is its text very poorly written, common for that time, when the rules were not so well-structured, but it also talks about using cards face down, instead of randomly deciding the results with a die. Therefore, it is quite possible that someone takes the card unknowingly and tries to use it in the old rules, causing even more confusion and headache.

Cocoon - Morph for sadness

Loading icon
This cocoon here works exactly like a butterfly. Cocoon enters by enchanting your creature and tapping it, while placing three counters, which will be removed one by one with each upkeep. On your fourth upkeep after your creature is enchanted, it will become a beautiful butterfly, gaining a +1/+1 counter and flying. You can do this, for example, to make that Tarmogoyf of yours super cool, stronger and with an evasion.

Ad

The question is, why would you do that when there are countless more efficient ways to inflict pain on yourself? Needless to say, taking a good creature out of play for a few turns to give it a flying ability counter and a little boost to its stats is a bad idea. Arcane Flight does the same for the same mana value. Worse, the creature is not magically hidden behind a phase switch, exile, hexproof, protection, or shroud, unless it already has one of those abilities. It's there, ready to take a Lightning Bolt, Wrath of God or even a spray of insecticide on the sleeve. It is indisputable that without the limitation of enchanting only your creatures, Cocoon would be a standard removal. With games getting faster and faster, the enchantment is a good way to balance reward and risk, making it possible to disarm an opponent's defense and go straight to victory. Other than that, Cocoon is recommended as a substitute for bad decisions.

Wood Elemental - Armageddon yourself

Loading icon
This one is party rice on every “Worst Cards in Magic” list ever made. Tell me, what's more genius than casting an Armageddon, confining all players to just their dorks and mana rocks, making the experience of playing Magic miserable? Exactly! Casting Armageddon only for yourself, which is possible with the Wood Elemental. This guy's level goes soooo much lower, really lower. So far, we've talked about cards with little or no use, which only cater for very specific situations. Wood Elemental is the first card that really puts us behind in the game. Although it costs four mana, we can only cast it when we have five mana available, the fifth being an untapped forest, which would give us a 1/1 creature. The little heavy tree grows exponentially with the number of UNTAPPED forests you use as an offering when it comes into play. So, for you to achieve an optimal result, using its abilities, it's a good idea to generate mana with creatures and artifacts, and sacrifice all your myriad of forests present in your field to the elemental, generating a creature with a lot of determination to win. Do you know what we can do with its huge body after you sacrificed your forests? Nothing! Wood Elemental doesn't have trample. It also doesn't have any form of evasion, surveillance, or any ability that takes advantage of its stats that we wish were monstrous. Just as it lacks total protection, causing the simplest removal, or deathtouch creature, to end our dreams, leaving our entire board decimated. The game of wiping out your own lands can seem like fun. And Wood Elemental is the perfect card for you to feel like a member of the agribusiness, which also destroys its own forests, but to raise livestock.

Brushwagg - The amighty Tojo

Loading icon
Brushwagg is a really nice guy, I love his name in Portuguese,

Tojo

. It begins that Brushwaggs are a race existing only in Magic, that is, it is an individual creation of the people of research and development. It might not be as bad as the other cards featured here, but this guy has history, and it's pleasant to talk about it in the article, to introduce him to those who never met him.

Ad

In addition, the Brushwagg are cards belonging to a select group called the Reserved List, cards that we know Wizards will never reprint, which makes them tend to value, since their number is finite, and even scarce at times. Due to its clumsy appearance and its effect considered inefficient, it is very popular to this day, for Meme reasons. Cards with bad effects, funny animals and other things are always very welcome and loved in any game, and the guy here is proof of that, which leads many to want to have their own copy of it, for sentimental reasons and for popularity. There is also a rumor of a colleague who has been purchasing Brushwaggs for years, accumulating many of them and having an increasingly fat collection of these animals. Brushwagg-type creatures made their return over two decades later in Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths, with Almighty Brushwagg. Along with the card that never left testing, but was revealed to us thanks to the Mystery Booster Interplanar Brushwagg, which means we will slowly make our way towards future tribal of creatures hidden in balls of dry grass.
Loading icon
Its effect makes it great as a defender, but terrible as an attacker, where it loses all the gas it could possibly have, being barely able to kill any threat unaided. This effect could easily be adjusted by making it gain power when blocked or toughness when blocking, but that would take some fun out of the pet, which has a huge place in our hearts.

Conclusion

Loading icon
From now on, this humble writer will dedicate his life to collecting as many copies of Cocoon as he can. Who knows, I might be able to do something cool with them, like a painting, a table, maybe a floor entirely made of them? The sky is the limit for these beauties, which will gain +1/+1 counters and fly! If you have any card suggestions that could be here, leave them in the comments! Until next time!
Profile imageSign in and join the conversation
User profile image

Be the first to comment

Profile Main Image

Pedro Braga

Future dentist and owner of the channel “Hora do Coelho” on Youtube. He knows how to make the best stroganoff you've ever eaten in your life and loves small animals. Has a Niv-Mizzet deck, Parun in Commander.

Social Instagram Brands icon

Same Author

Top 5 best Urzas for Commander

Best Character decks

Top 5 best Urzas for Commander

We've finally come to a point in which we have many playable Urzas in Magic, and enough fo...

Modern: Top 5 cards from The Brothers' War

Top 5 Modern

Modern: Top 5 cards from The Brothers' War

In today's article, let's review the five best cards from The Brothers' War for Modern!

Group Slug EDH: Top 5 Commanders

Group Slug Commanders

Group Slug EDH: Top 5 Commanders

In the quest to present different commanders and strategies, we arrived at Group Slug, a s...

Modern review: Top 5 best cards from Dominaria United

Dominaria United & Modern

Modern review: Top 5 best cards from Dominaria United

Dominaria United, brings us wonderful cards for the Modern format. In today's article, we...

Top 5 Best Burn Commanders for EDH

Top 5 Commanders

Top 5 Best Burn Commanders for EDH

In this Commander article, we talk about Magic's most popular archetype, Burn!

Top 5 Best Commanders for Group Hug

Group Hug

Top 5 Best Commanders for Group Hug

In this article, we discuss the five best commanders for Group Hug, a fun strategy which h...

More from same author

Most read articles today

Top 10 Most Scary and Frightening MTG Artworks

Top 10 Scary Artworks

Top 10 Most Scary and Frightening MTG Artworks

This is an article to scare you with old artworks and find out why Magic was the target of...

The Brothers’ War: Ranking ALL Commanders from the set

All Commanders from BRO!

The Brothers’ War: Ranking ALL Commanders from the set

In today’s article we rank ALL 45 potential Commanders and their supplementing products! ...

Top 10 Best Preconstructed Commander Decks

Top 10 Commander Precons

Top 10 Best Preconstructed Commander Decks

A Top 10 of the best preconstructed Commander decks ever released, ranked by Commander, Sy...

Upgrading Commander Precon:  Urza's Iron Alliance (Urza, Chief Artificer)

Upgrading Urza's Iron Alliance

Upgrading Commander Precon: Urza's Iron Alliance (Urza, Chief Artificer)

An analysis of The Brothers' War Commander Precon: Urza's Iron Alliance, the artifact them...

Upgrading Commander Precon: Mishra's Burnished Banner

Mishra's Commander Upgrade

Upgrading Commander Precon: Mishra's Burnished Banner

This is an analysis of the pre-constructed deck "Mishra's Burnished Banner", commanded by ...

Top 10 Weirdest and funniest Commanders in Magic

Top 10 Commanders

Top 10 Weirdest and funniest Commanders in Magic

In this Top 10 for Commander, we will see some of the most insane creatures with the weird...

Top 5 best Urzas for Commander

Best Character decks

Top 5 best Urzas for Commander

We've finally come to a point in which we have many playable Urzas in Magic, and enough fo...

The Japanese Alternative Arts of StrixHaven's Mystical Archive cards

The Japanese Alternative Arts of StrixHaven's Mystical Archive cards

The Japanese website of Wizards of the Coast revealed the 63 arts that will only be possib...

Modern: Izzet Murktide Deck Tech & Sideboard Guide

Modern Izzet Murktide

Modern: Izzet Murktide Deck Tech & Sideboard Guide

Izzet Murktide is Modern's current best deck, but it's also challenging to play it masterf...

X
Hi